Professor Oak after Ash leaves Pallet Town

>>59644301
>he fucks delia

>>59644297
Ash wins Indigo League, retires. A 3 year timeskip occurs, and we follow a new protag in Johto based on Gold who travels with Whitney and either Falkner or Bugsy. End of the series, in an arc equivelant to the Orange Islands, NotGold goes to Kanto and challenges each gym there and learns about Ash.

I don't think he'd be on Mount Silver like the edgy Red, but both him and NotGold would battle and end the series with NotGold winning the battle.

Then the next series follows Brendan, son of Professor Birch, and May, daughter of Norman. Brendan would be the battler, and May would be the Contest Star. There would be two more companions, but I have no ideas for them yet. AG would end with the two winning their respective Leagues, and the two would finish it off with a battle to decide the better trainer. (Probably Brendan). Then the two would go to the Kanto Battle Frontier to challenge the Frontier Brains, and it'd be cool if Ash became an anime-exclusive Frontier Brain.

The next series is Diamond and Pearl and it follows a similar formula to the previous series, with Lucas and Dawn being protags in the battling and contest roles respectively. There would be a third anime-exclusive companion with them that would want to be a Pokemon Doctor. They could do a Johto Battle Frontier arc at the end, but then it'd just be AG with a filter on. Also NotGold would appear in this series at some point to promote HGSS.

Then Unova's next which should've been where Ash retired in real life, but I digress. Hilbert, Cilan and Iris (fuck Hilda) travel Unova and the series is basically just Best Wishes but written better without Ash.

XY is perfect as it is, but if Ash is retired at this point, we can just put Calem instead of him and the plot works just fine. Maybe to make it interesting, the AG protagonists return in their ORAS designs.

>>59644297
Can you anime pieces of shit just fucking stay on /padt/?

>>59644316
So we'll get Calem-Greninja too?

>>59644297
The anime general is a few blocks to the left.

>Ashnimemaggots needing another thread on the catalog for attention
>Dumping the same question in the subject field, username and text field.
Can the gentlemen just kick their asses back into the containment general already?

>>59644329
Ideally not

>>59644327
That place is a shithole, and I'd rather have 10 anime threads than one thread about smashing underage pokegirls

File: 1717306945390.jpg (55 KB, 500x500)

55 KB JPG

>>59644415 >>59648921

>>59644394
>I'd rather have 10 anime threads than one thread about smashing underage pokegirls

File: 4t6y1qf76g4f1.jpg (77 KB, 1080x762)

77 KB JPG

>>59644394

>>59644405
>look sylveon,
>a pedophile

File: 1734565523478.jpg (40 KB, 492x368)

40 KB JPG

>>59644415

>>59644394
>That place is a shithole
>So I'll drag out the autism publicly instead
Lowest IQ response ever. Same crap but spread out.

>>59644415
Sir, Pokegirls are drawings.

File: image.png (2.38 MB, 2113x1587)

2.38 MB PNG

>>59644476 >>59644494 >>59644509 >>59644516 >>59646081 >>59663988 >>59668553 >>59670458 >>59670637 >>59680055 >>59680074

>>59644316
In another life....

>>59644473
They look so kino together

>>59644473
The characters had a lot more charm before their redesigns, why is that?

>>59644494
Nostalgia. Just look at Morty's original design.

>>59644473
What we could've had if Takeshi Shudo was still alive

>>59644494
Nu-Whitney is sex though.

File: image.png (1.56 MB, 2390x1727)

1.56 MB PNG

>>59644473
Another one for fun

Finally a good thread desu

>>59644316
>(fuck hilda)
You'd be surprised how many would take this offer

Buuuuuuuuump

>>59644473
To imitate the callback in G/S they could have Gold fight Ash at the end.

>>59646081
That's what I said in >>59644316

>>59644316
Did you make teams for these?

>>59646410
Pokecharms crashed on me.

>>59646410
Give me a second

>>59646410
For the Johto series -

Hiro (Gold):
>Cyndaquil -> Quilava -> Typhlosion
>Egg -> Pichu -> Pikachu
>Heracross
>Chikorita -> Bayleef -> Meganium
>Totodile -> Croconaw -> Feraligatr
>Phanpy -> Donphan

Whitney:
>Clefairy -> Clefable
>Miltank
>Lickitung

Falkner:
>Hoothoot -> Noctowl
>Dodrio
>Pidgeotto -> Pidgeot

For the Hoenn series -

Landon (Brendan):
>Treeko -> Grovyle -> Sceptile
>Plusle
>Taillow -> Swellow
>Torkoal
>Snorunt -> Glalie
>Trapinch -> Vibrava -> Flygon

Marina (May):
>Torchic -> Combusken -> Blaziken
>Minun
>Wurmple -> Silcoon -> Beautifly
>Skitty -> Delcatty
>Baltoy -> Claydol
>Swablu -> Altaria

Unknown Third Companion:
>Mudkip -> Marshtomp -> Swampert
>I got nothing else.

Unknown Fourth Companion:
>I got nothing.

For the Sinnoh series -

Lucas:
>Turtwig -> Grotle -> Torterra
>Shinx -> Luxio -> Luxray
>Starly -> Staravia -> Staraptor
>Buizel -> Floatzel
>Riolu -> Lucario
>Gible -> Gabite -> Garchomp

Dawn:
>Piplup -> Prinplup -> Empoleon
>Buneary -> Lopunny
>Pachirisu
>Aipom -> Ambipom
>Magmar -> Magmortar
>Eevee -> Glaceon

Unknown Third Companion:
>Chimchar -> Monferno -> Infernape
>I got nothing else.

For the Unova series -

Hilbert:
>Oshawott -> Dewott -> Samurott
>Pidove -> Tranquill -> Unfezant
>Blitzle -> Zebstrika
>Sewaddle -> Swadloon -> Leavanny
>Munna -> Musharna (idk man)
>Krokorok -> Krookodile

Iris:
>Axew -> Fraxure -> Haxorus
>Drilbur -> Excadrill
>Emolga
>Egg -> Scraggy -> Scrafty
>Archeops
>Druddigon

Cilan:
>Pansage -> Simisage
>Tepig -> Pignite -> Emboar
>Basculin
>Dwebble -> Crustle
>Stunfisk
>not sure if he'd have a full team or not.

That's all I have for now.

>>59646468
Instead of Archeops, I'd give her Snivy -> Servine -> Serperior instead.

>>59646487
Is this the same world where Gamefreak had the balls to make Serperior Grass/Dragon?

Buuuuump the dying thread

>>59646468
Good team ideas, what about XY, SM, and SWSH?

>>59648011
XY would just be the same teams really. Maybe instead of Pikachu, Calem has a Heliolisk idk.

>>59644316
The pacing of generations+remakes makes this look so easy to where I wish they'd just went with it to begin with. Digimon and Yu-Gi-Oh! had the right idea with closing out each cast and having callbacks/returning characters, deciding to follow Ash for like 25 years was nuts.

>>59648376
In another world, it was Digimon that stuck with the original cast. Takeshi Shudo believed the anime should have a new protagonist every series, if only they listened to him.

>>59648535
He actually believed the series should've just ended. Nobody at OLM thought there'd be more than two gens at the time the decision to keep Satoshi for Johto was made.

>>59648749
Also, the gen 1 anime ended long before the gen 2 games released. The decision to extend the anime so it could promote the upcoming gen 2 games was made, which is why we got the Orange Islands arc instead of a longer Kanto arc. Replacing Ash when gen 2 started after you had already made an anime original quest for him to go on to kill time until gen 2 started would've made NO sense.

>>59644316
So Basically your entire idea for every new series is the new protagonist just repeating the same journey where he collects the eight gym badge, win league, become champions and then leaves for new protagonist to do the same exact thing? The fact that you haven't seen the error with this showcase you didn't even think hard enough. You basically want each series to be a Mary Sue wish fulfillment fantasy where the world will bend to the new protagonist's will like Pokémon Horizons.

The thing that made Original series special was original Ash being an actual underdog protagonist with nothing special and the world didn't bend to his will which mades him relatable and compelling for people to root from him and follow his story which is why Ashnime formula worked. If you remove all that with each series having Mary Sue protagonist who guarantee to win at the end then there won't be any stakes and people won't care about them to watch the new series after the Original series.

What? You think each series should be about new protagonist taking on forces of evil or take other challenges. They can can do the same thing with Ash taking on forces of evil or other challenges as well. The only difference is that Ash would already have the experience and skill to take on forces of evil unlike a new protagonist staring from scratch.

The Truth is , people obsessed with protagonist rotation doesn't understand a thing. They think pokemon has to rotate protagonist solely because that's what Digimon and Yu-Gi-Oh did without even seeing the difference between the series. The original writers did actually thought about how each series would work with new protagonist which is why they decided to keep Ash rather than risk betting on new protagonist.

File: o0xhcqnw52wc1[1].jpg (93 KB, 853x480)

93 KB JPG

>>59648932 >>59649006

>>59648899
>every new series is the new protagonist just repeating the same journey
that's just how precure works

>>59644405
>Look Sylveon,

>A Typhlosion

>>59648919
Dont give the homeless schizo any attention. He twists everything said while projecting all his retardation or insecurities towards everyone else.

File: EpOQ2xsWEKKIIjZ.png (326 KB, 675x462)

326 KB PNG

>>59648899
Lots of autism radiating from this post

>>59648899
>The original writers did actually thought about how each series would work with new protagonist which is why they decided to keep Ash rather than risk betting on new protagonist.

No they didn't KEK

>>59648919
No, Precure work by shilling new Eye candies in magical girl uniform fighting evil in each new series to attract boys That's not how pokemon work, its like comparing Precure with Sailor Moon.

File: 1674850804548771.png (317 KB, 569x298)

317 KB PNG

>>59649293

>>59649006
Yeah, Pokemon instead shills new Eye candies in regular clothes fighting evil in each new series to attract boys.
But is it really that much of a difference?

chaging protagonist just kil the series happened to ygo now pkmn even in digimon bb ended and it's already forgotten people still remember adventures trio

>>59649224
And all of them are shipped with Ash for a reason.

>>59649272
happened to db and naruto too lol boruto sales mangas are embarrassing compared to naruto and they are making another new anime with naruto

>>59649293
Sure for the SI-maggots but that doesn't sound as nice as you want it to be right? Fuck off, F aggot.

>>59649323
Unlike you, I have a common sense & look around myself. Nobody gave a dam about Koharu or Liko because they were never shipped with him or had any major interaction with him. While Serena constantly tops every poll despite her bland personality simply for having a crush on Ash.

Eye-candy in anipoke only matter when they are shipped with Ash.

>>59649333
>Unlike you, I have a common sense
Not enough common sense to hide your SI faggotry or downgrading every other character imaginable to build the hick up while accusing others of your bullshit. No enough common sense to not dox yourself as a phonefaggot who got evicted by his own parents above the age of 30. For being so daft to every other opinion except yourself and your face in the puddle on the street, your definition of common sense is just as terrible as your retarded insinuations that Pokemon should just constantly copy or follow other non-Pokemon shows that you bring up unprompted. Do yourself and the poor people who have to put up with you in person and just step off the web to get a job, maybe you can actually get actual experience and some ideas of what common sense actually means.

>>59649354
All that rant & flaming yet you didn't haven't prove a thing. In fact except one guy, nobody bother to talk about how each anime series could work with different protagonist. Why? Because most smart & sensible people already have realized why new protagonist on each series won't going to work in less than 3 mouth after Horizons started. Only Ash hating schizo like you still hold on to the idea of protagonist rotation.

>>59649632
You straight up went to the jugular of others but can't handle when they do the same to you? Enough said about your pathetic attitude that drove you into the dirt. Countless times was it reinvigorated why stagnation comes with dragging out a stay but no, nothing counts for your shallow ass. Get a job you embarrassment of a grown adult.

>>59644297
Waiting for more ideas...

>>59649916
There is no idea, the only way to pull it off is Ash being a side character like Cynthia or Lance that assist the new protagonist from sideline.

https://gelbooru.com/index.php?page=post&s=view&id=15030025

Ask yourself this, how would you set up a new protagonist on Gen 10? They can not be a Mary sue , a prodigy,no special ancestors, no magic destiny, wouldn't get any legendary/mythical pokemon, not unbeatable & must follow all the restriction that Ash, Dawn & May had to follow.

Bumping the Satoshi thread

File: 1.png (652 KB, 1920x1080)

652 KB PNG

>>59651942 >>59652449 >>59652732

>>59644297

I have two ideas: one that follows a timeline with Ash involved, but as a recurring character/deuterogamist/mentor, and then one that is mostly separate in continuity, with only minor reappearances to promote remakes

Timeline 1: Ash as a constant recurring character, but not protagonist, of the anime

File: 2.png (612 KB, 1920x1080)

612 KB PNG

>>59652449 >>59652732

>>59651936
Continuation of the first timeline (Ash as a present recurring presence, but never the main protaganist)

It is here where you can probably tell my lack of care/knowledge for nu-gen anime and games. Also just burnt out by this point of writing lol.

>>59651936
>>59651942
Two freaking complicated and you still favoring Alain.

make a likeable main characters and with decent design not the boring ugly crap called liko roy

>>59651936
>>59651942
Awesome ideas!

More than 24 hours passed & yet nobody able to answer this >>59650244.

>>59653354
What do you mean by restriction?

>>59653371
Guys a schizoid who will undermine anything and anyone else who aren't the characters listed because he's a jaded lolcow who made Ash his life and will antagonize or project his bullshit onto others.

The tranime never will be good because they dont have the balls for replace pikchu

>>59653354
Because you're a faggot lol

>>59653371
Means new protagonist can't be some Mary sue self insert living their wish fulfillment fantasy & has to be actual characters bound by the same rules that all the other characters had to follow.

>>59653502
You simply can't think of a good gen 10 anime with a new protagonist. Every idea you can think or thought off only gets better when Ash is on the protagonist place.

>>59654145
>ash ash ash
You are one sad individual

File: 800px-LoT_first_partners.png (535 KB, 800x423)

535 KB PNG

>>59655355 >>59655980 >>59658309

As a kid, I always wanted to follow the journeys of these 3 since watching the Raikou movie/special.

They didn't have to travel together; focus on Jimmy and he occasionally bumps into the others or have an episode focus on Jimmy, the next another protagonist, etc.

Just felt like the early 2000s edgy teen version of Pokémon protagonists like Jaiden Yuki

>>59654145
You are literally telling people to just make Ash 2.0. Fuck you

>>59655321
Would've been so amazing, I like how they're color coordinated

Buuuuuuump

>>59655321
jimmy in 4 episodes was better than ash

>>59655980
and one of the reason is because there is not pikachu

File: Jennys.jpg (60 KB, 447x447)

60 KB JPG

>>59684523

The Jenny Show!

>>59652449
not complicated at all and if every mc won their league it would get boring quick. xy is shit no matter what, get over it

>>59652732
thank you!!! :)

>>59657452
Got any more ideas?

File: KYS.gif (1.16 MB, 320x179)

1.16 MB GIF

>>59657427
>xy is shit

Ashmongs really can't handle the fact that XY was the last time people agreed the anime was good instead of just doing autistic "he won the league so that makes the series good no matter how bad the rest of it was" damage control.

>>59658175
SM was really good though. It's JN that was so fucking awful.

File: 1560946637881.jpg (121 KB, 1199x657)

121 KB JPG

>>59658318

>>59658257
>SM was really good though

>>59655321
I always thought Pokémon Chronicles was an experiment to see how the viewership would react the anime having new protagonists

>>59658308
Not enough fun and whimsy in your life, it's sad really

>>59657427
>if every mc won their league it would get boring quick.
So you entire idea is to give special privileges to one protagonist while treat another like crap just like XY&Z series did?

>>59658309
"Pokemon Chronicles" was the dub name for a bunch of unrelated previously undubbed specials and was not meant to be anything other than "let's finally dub these things".

>>59658257
>>59658318
>unironically defending SM of all things
Dumb underageb&

File: 444.png (371 KB, 446x572)

371 KB PNG

>>59658872 >>59663232

too late

>>59658380
Better than JN, BW and AG by a mile.

>>59658392
And add the Johto arc in here too.

>>59658175
>Ashmongs really can't handle the fact that XY was the last time people agreed the anime was good
That was DP series , not XY or XY&Z.
Only Amourshippers and Alain's fan tries to call it good and they are among the same minorities that believe SM series to be a good series.

>>59658386
Demon Slayer is so ass

>>59658860
Holy ESL

>>59658872
Still more popular than Pokemon tranime

>>59659379
>tranime
Kek

>>59644297
Pokemon anime needs to return to its root with Ash, Brock, New Girl exploring a single region while being stalked by Team Rocket gang.

>>59660826
That's never happening. Cope and seethe.

>>59658386
At the end, Ash + TRio + Game character were the best cast.

>>59644473
Would've flopped

>>59663988
No it wouldn't have, stop doomposting faggot.

>>59664369
Hey wut BUMP'in?!

>>59664654
Jerking off to this comment, thanks anon!

>>59660826
Why would they re-do an idea that ended 10 years ago? Think, anon.

>>59665794
Because it worked for 20 years unlike Horizons that already run out of ideas.

>>59666732
>Can't shut up about Horizons
Was gonna say you should just go suck a dick, Fagmon but you'd probably enjoy considering how much you suck Ash off you homeless maggot.

File: 1468936027535.png (51 KB, 434x439)

51 KB PNG

>>59666743

>>59666743
Crying and rant again because you still have no arguments.

>>59664040
Nobody talks about Legends of Thunder outside of Jimmy is an accurate model for an older mature Ash. At the end, the special wasn't that popular compared to any Ashnime episode.

>>59644316
It always felt weird watching Ash travel to Hoenn and leave Misty behind to pursue her gym leader career, only for Brock to tag alone anyway despites also being a gym leader in Kanto. I'd much rather they all stayed behind and only showed up in select episodes of each series.

>>59644473
Genuine, unfiltered kino. Whitney as a chaotic as fuck traveling companion choice and Falkner is the perfect straight man to Ethan and Whitney

>>59668542
Because it got no exposure while the main anime took center stage.

You're not being objective if you think Jimmy fails when he's the ONLY protagonist of the Pokemon mainline anime. That's just denial.

File: admap-dsk-1-19-12-1_hpz7.2496.jpg (273 KB, 2496x1398)

273 KB JPG

>>59668798

>>59653439
It basically all circles back to this. Ash for all intents and purposes was never the real main protagonist, it was Pikachu. You 'could' replace Ash as the protagonist at any moment, but how do you explain the mascot of the entire franchise not being a constant presence in the anime? The other canon game characters who are good candidates to replace Ash don't have this one Pokemon, and that alone was the dealbreaker.

>>59667903
>>59668542
Get a life Fagmon. The hick is gone, people couldn't care less, the anime continues without him and projecting your tantrums won't change that.

>>59668574
>You 'could' replace Ash as the protagonist at any moment,
This kind of mindset is what lead to trashes like Roy & Friede. The show writers saw comment like these & thought " If we bring taller handsome Mary sues with Pikachu then everybody will forget about Ash and start fangirling our self insert". But it didn't work and would never work as proven by Pokemon Horizons.

Ash worked because he was relatable & compelling enough to make people care about his story. It doesn't matter how many MC you bring with a Pikachu, they won't reach the popularity of Ash without his compelling characteristics. But again there is no point in telling people like you this because in your eyes. only good protagonist are self inserted trash like Jin-woo who magically become tall, handsome , super-strong within two episode and have girls simps over him while all other men are only in the story to be fodder to glorify him.

>>59668553
THIS. It would've been the perfect travelling group for a Gen 2 anime.

>>5964429
>Gen 2:
Anime about Ethan solving a "quest of the week" while making friends both with his pokemon and the recurring characters who can call at his pokegear at any moment
>Gen 3:
Comedic anime about Brendan being a nature obsessed survivalist who goes from explores the wilds of Hoenn to doing goofy hijinks in a more civilized setting
>Gen 4:
Slowburn emotional story between Dawn and Lucas alternating comfy SoL episodes with lore-driven mysteries
>Gen 5:
Full blown spectacle battle shonen that drops the isolated episodic formula for a more classic arc based story where Hilbert and Hilda are challenged not only in battle, but in morality
>Gen 6:
A mix between Gen 4's lore focus and Gen 5's edginess where Clem, Serena and AZ travel across Kalos with a clear purpose to prevent the end of the world
Gen 7:
IDK just make a Journeys nostalgiafest where Elio goes WAKU WAKU at every recognizable character he sees lol

>>59670133
Nice ideas kek

>>59670133
None of them are nearly as interesting as Ash's gym quest. I mean you don't even need new protagonist for any of those idea since Ash pretty much can do all of them but better.

>>59670186
>>59668585

>>59670186
Wish you'd get IP banned Fagnon

>>59644473
That would've been GOAT'd.

>>59670458
I wonder if I could cook up some episode ideas for a What If? Gold and Silver anime...

Would /vp/ accept this?

>>59670579
Yes, please. We'd luv it.

>>59670579
First we have to end off Ash's series.

Ash would win against Ritchie in EP079. He'd compete in the quarterfinals in EP080 and the semifinals in EP081. The finals would be a two-parter (EP082 and EP083), and Ash would win the Indigo League in the latter.

Ash, Misty and Brock return to Pallet Town to celebrate Ash's victory before Ash challenges the Elite Four.

>EP085 - Filler episode on Victory Road
>EP086 - VS Lorelai
>EP087 - VS Bruno
>EP088 - VS Agatha
>EP089 - VS Lance
>EP090 - VS Anime-Exclusive Champion. Ash becomes the new Kanto Champion!
>EP091 to EP093 - The road back to Pallet Town.
>EP094 and EP095 - Ash VS Giovanni Part 1 and 2.
>EP096 (get it because 1996) - Ash says goodbye to Brock and Misty.
>EP097 - The final episode. Ends like the real final episode of the series (Rainbow and the Pokemon Master).

Next reply will include the episode titles.

>>59670609
How much ESLglish will these titles have?

>>59670609
>EP085: Victory Road! Challenging Battles!!
>EP086: Kanto League! VS Lorelai!!
>EP087: Kanto League! VS Bruno!!
>EP088: Kanto League! VS Agatha!!
>EP089: Kanto League! VS Lance!!
>EP090: Winner's Trophy! Full Battle 6 VS 6!!
>EP091: Final Battle! Enter Dragonite!
>EP092: To the End of the Journey! Each One's Way!
>EP093: Rival Showdown! Ash VS Gary!!
>EP094: Team Rocket Attacks! Part 1
>EP095: Team Rocket Attacks! Part 2
>EP096: Goodbye...and Then, Setting Off!
>EP097: The Rainbow and the Pokémon Master...!

>>59670613
A lot

File: Screenshot 2026-10-18 170614.png (55 KB, 1252x127)

55 KB PNG

>>59670645

>>59670620
Fitting release date for the last Ash episode.

>>59670620
Would the anime go on a hiatus in between the Ash and GS series?

>>59670630
I mean probably. GS come out in November 99, and the anime would have no material from May to then.

>>59670631
>no material from may to then
Didn't stop the current anime series from making filler episodes that will last over a year.

>>59670609
>>59670620
I am the same OP that wrote >>59644316,
>>59644473 and >>59646468 btw.

>>59670637
Next up, the titles for the GS anime. This may take awhile.

>>59670628
What the fuck is up with that retarded ass translation?

>>59670645
That's just how the Pokemon dub titles were named.

>>59663988
impossible to flop harder than Ash already did in gen 2

>>59670644
Please hurry

>>59670633
Only because WiWa got delayed due to leakerfags spoiling the entire game two years before.

File: 1791410229889374.jpg (219 KB, 1240x1171)

219 KB JPG

>>59670854
>wiwa

>>59670781
Gen 02 series was a much better hit than all the non-Ashnime pokemon anime

>>59671809
It literally lost 50% viewership in a single gen

>>59671809
TRVTH NVKE!!!!1!!1!!1!11!!!!!!

>>59671809
Kek

>>59671809
>a festering pile of shit is better than a festering pile of rotten shit
Animefags really setting the bar high huh

>>59671825
Proof?

>>59671901
Japan's tv ratings are literally documented

File: eyebrow.png (141 KB, 439x439)

141 KB PNG

>>59671927

>>59671915
>says something
>is asked to show proof
>"it's literally documented bro"

>>59671915
Lul, because companies don't misrepresent viewership numbers. Of course....

File: Jimmy would have prevente(...).png (93 KB, 438x906)

93 KB PNG

>>59671976 >>59672069 >>59674628

>>59671918
This is what happens you use Ash instead of Jimmy

>>59671927
There we go, proof! Thanks, anon.

>>59670644
We need the titles anon!

>>59672015
Calm down anon, I have a life outside of /vp/.

>>59671927
Still a better rating than Pokemon Horizon. In fact Pokemon was on per with show like Doraemon, Maruko chan and Crayon Shin chan.

>>59672069
Nobody watched horizons or JN

>>59672071
Speaking from personal experience?

Fuuuuuuuck imagine living in a world where ashfags don't exist

>>59672731
I think they'd be even worse in this timeline.

>>59670133
You idea for Gen 02 to Gen 4 is basically just a longer "Aim To Be Pokemon Master" series. In fact I don't even understand why any of them require new protagonist since Slice OF Life anime are carried by its original characters & doesn't get rid of any of their characters.

>>59668798
>Friede
Ok retard, explain what's wrong with him?

>>59673329
Boring , irresponsible, incompetent , the anime was too busy trying to make him look cool rather than mature & competent. Brock alone was a better leader than this guy.

>>59673440
So it contrasts with your babbling from earlier? Your rants are inconsistent as shit. Get help and an English book, fucking retard.

>>59644297
They should bring him back.

>>59644316
>NotGold goes to Kanto and challenges each gym there
After a short hiatus and the Hoenn arc has started. Gen 3 takes more of a teen oriented approach where the story is focused more on Brendan taking out both Aqua and Magma while his companion May is very interested in contests. The gym league is no longer a central focus on in the Hoenn arc. When FRLG gets closer they resume NotGold's journey across the Kanto region while bringing back the classic league formula after fans have been asking for it, and these two animes coexist alongside each other until Sinnoh comes along and brings in the best elements of these two animes. When BW comes along the series takes another tonal shift that focuses more on a late teen audience while Jessie and James get their own anime to give young kids something to watch.

>>59674611
In this timeline FRLG is also not treated as an unnecessary "faithful remake". Towns are expanded. Johto Pokemon are found in the wild. Cinnabar Island actually has a volcano. You also get to explore Johto after beating the league with a completely new storyline.

>>59674618
HGSS also doesn't happen in this timeline as it's seen as redundant with the existence of FRLG, and instead BW has more time being developed. Most expansive world yet. Eventually Gen 2 does get a revisit in the place of the Let's GO games.

>>59671927
Tbf the original writers were losing interest in the middle of the original series and everything felt phoned in. The viewers may have been kids, but kids back then could tell if something wasn't being made with love.

>>59649299
>they are making another new anime with naruto
What

>>59674611
>Brendan taking out both Aqua and Magma
How ? Why? Brendan start as protagonist from Gen III anime which mean he should be newbie staring with level 05 starter. Are you suggesting that he will magically become strong enough to take down two most evil organization Hoenn single handily that the entire law enforcement of Hoenn fails to do because he is the main protagonist? Why would these two evil organization would even give a dam about a newbie staring with new pokemon? What would Brendan even have that they want?

Did you saw the flaw in your idea? You are not writing a story, you are writing a Mary Sue fantasy. Don't use game logic on me because anime & game are different. There is a reason game Mario can take out Brower single-handily but movie Mario needed Luigi, Donkey Kong , Peach and super powerup to fight Brower.

Whom I kidding, you think XY series was perfect which shows your poor standard considering XY series was just a Mary Sue power fantasy about Alain.

>>59675568
>guh why a newbie with level 05 starter take down two evil teams? i think you write mary sue fantasy
Do you know what franchise you're talking about? You might be a fucking retard. Go seek professional help.

How easy would it be to whip up something with AI? Ive already seen accurate depictions of a lifelike Naruto as a series. I know nothing of AI and don't know what models are good

>>59675568
You mean like how Gold takes out a high ranking team rocket admin before he even evolves his Cyndaquil?

>>59675720
A day later and not a response lol

Ash should've retired after Gen 4. Have him win the Sinnoh League, and move on without him. That way Gen 5 can still exist in its form but have a character replace Ash.

Only issue is that'd mean XY wouldn't have Ash, which is a weird thing to think about.

Buuuuuump

>>59644297
The anime died years ago.

>>59678079
If it died, then why is there still an ongoing anime series?

Think, monkey.

>>59678561
No, the anime did die. What you see now is it's shambling zombie corpse.

>>59676276
>Ash should've retired after Gen 4.
I'd say Gen 2, but not a bad choice.

>>59676276
>>59679781
Still would've have flopped.
All of you are still hung up on the idea that pokemon supposed to be Digimon/Precure despite their fundamental difference in their premise. Pokemon is similar to series like Dragonball & Sailor Moon than Digimon/Precure.

Protagonist Rotation could only worked on pokemon anime if Ash was a massive Mary Sue who won all the time and become champion within first season however the series wouldn't had be as lovable & memorable as OS series and would have gotten shut down before Gen 3..

>>59679849
Pokemon would be better off if it had a proper ending and was allowed to rest in peace. Stretching Ash's journey out to a quarter of a century was a mistake. Pokemon continuing after Gen 4 was a mistake.

>>59679901
>Pokemon continuing after Gen 4 was a mistake.
Objectively false

File: fe92927c-2b6b-43d0-a8f2-e(...).gif (190 KB, 400x215)

190 KB GIF

>>59680008
>Objectively
Look at this fool throwing around a new word he saw.

>>59644473
Miltank would be an terror in an ongoing anime...

I'm all for it

>>59680055
>ongoing
In this hypothetical world, the GS anime would've ended 24 years ago.

>>59644473
Who is the best male protagonist design, and why is it Ethan?

>>59680074
>Who is the best male protagonist design, and why is it Gold?

>>59679849
if ash left in gen 3 or earlier, the anime would've flopped, gen 4 onwards was safe enough to remove ash without much issue

>>59679901
>>59680100
>Pokemon would be better off if it had a proper ending
You can say the same exact thing about every long running anime.

You still keep believing Anipoke to be some deep plot driven anime with an overreaching plot when it was always a character driven slice of life anime with no actual plot. This series purely carried by Ash and TRio therefore removing them would remove the driving force of the series that drove people to keep watching the show as proven by Horizons. Its like watching Dragonball without Goku or Bleach without Ichigo.

>Stretching Ash's journey out to a quarter of a century was a mistake. Pokemon continuing after Gen 4 was a mistake.
Stretching Ash's story gave it the longevity, it wasn't the mistake,. The actual mistake was halting Ash's progression from BW series and refused to let him win anything. The anime should have let Ash win the championship on BW series and gone full slice of life adventure anime with Ash exploring various region with new companions like Fireren.

The story of Horizon didn't require Ash to leave, it required Ash to stay

>>59680256
>gone full slice of life adventure anime with Ash exploring various region with new companions like Fireren.
Lmao

>>59680256
>You can say the same exact thing about every long running anime.
Yes... and I do.

>>59682040
Yet everytime they try a new protagonist, its fails. At this moment you just have Precure which survives by bringing new eye candies after Yugioh got shut down.

>>59682040
This anon gets it.

>>59644297
Indigo League concludes with Gary winning, but with Ash learning more important lessons about what a Pokemon master really is and sets up a more long term path to be the very best. Perhaps he could have won by pushing his Pokemon at the end but throws the match when he remembers his journey and believes that trust and care are important to cultivate your pokemon mastery. Kind of kike perhaps how the Cars movie ended and what happened after but better

Then in G/S you can follow notGold who wants to be a professor. He is Elm's assistant. Series starts with him running the Mr. Pokemon errand like in the game with Cyndaquil, having an Ash-Pikachu like binding moment with some Beedrill or something. They make it and oak sees his potential and gives him a dex. He returns home with the Pokemon and egg and silver has stolen the Pokemon. Elm says notGold has impressed him and beseaches him to travel Johto and complete the dex. Meanwhile the actual league challenge should be Silver's main quest in order to prove his strength and independence to daddy. notGold can get badges but mostly incidental, like he needs to catch Dratini but Claire wont let him into the den until he beats her

In Hoenn it also starts like in the games. Brendan's dad is the gym leader. It is pretty straightforward, he wants to be like his dad. May is the cute bait for puberty age boys whose already experienced and teaches brendan things. They agree to travel together, her dong field research for Birch (ties into game mechanics) and doing the contexts on the side while Brendan does the gym challenge cause she still loves girly stuff

I'll think of more later

>>59683525
No joke, I actually like these ideas anon.

>>59683525
Such kino ideas, can't wait for more!

Would Ash return in the G/S series like Red does?

>>59683525
Sounds even worse than the Original series.

>>59683623
Low effort ragebait.

File: bait.jpg (3 KB, 125x125)

3 KB JPG

>>59683930

>>59683623

>>59683623
>>59683675
>>59683709
>>59683525
Anon , your entire idea is basically turning rivals into Mary Sues. Gary was even more narcissistic , spoiled, self centered, over confident and ruder than Ash ever was and believe himself to be inherently superior than others. Losing the Indigo League was the wake up call he needed to humble himself & become a proper trainer. While Ash lost the Indigo League to somebody more mature than him and learn to accept loss & move on after watching the same person to do the same

You still making the same mistake as everybody else in this thread, you still believe that everybody wants a deep mature serious story with philosophical message but only some oversmart minority cares about that. Most people are simple and they only want simple stories. Nobody gave a dam about the meaning of pokemon master, they only want to watch Ash winning championship. They doesn't care about pokemon master unless it has something to do with winning championshipl

>>59683930
Your mistake is thinking all of these anons are the same person. Keep coping, faggot.

>>59644297
I propose everyone not twelve years old is banned from watching anime aimed at young children.

>>59684069
>spoken on the pokemon board

>>59684077
Own that faggot

>>59683525
Please come back with more ideas

>>59656009
More like Titto

File: EEUen1PUcAAhzOM.jpg (23 KB, 567x350)

23 KB JPG

>>59683525
Would watch

>>59644297
Ash is the best protagonist

How did this thread get so many replies?

>>59690315
People hate Ash Ketchum, except for one fagmon in this thread

>>59690315
Turned out there is no actual good idea to replace Ash with another protagonist .

>>59690399
Keep coping faggot

>>59691326
This thread was made 23 days ago and almost all idea so far involve new protagonist being some sort of Mary Sue. The only other idea is somehow worse than what Original series did.

Lets be honest, you all talk big about how removing Ash would somehow fix the anime but none of you have any idea how the anime would even work with new protagonist. You are simply obsessed with protagonist rotation because that's what Digimon did.

>>59691384
>Calling every idea that doesn't revolve or loops back to the hick terrible or Mary sue
You're a homeless lolcow over the age of 35 on the streets of Bangladesh by admission of self-doxxing getting mad at others not sucking off your every whim even after getting anons banned for months or permanently because they do not cocksuck your takes, you accuse them of shit you either are doing yourself, lie about events and things to cover your cardboard deep bullshit, antagonized waifufags where you didn't jerked off to their character at the time for years by belittling them, starting shit between generals and then came back crawling to them with your terribly ripped off fanfictions with the hick as your SI to get favors or support because this type of validation is the only thing you have left in your life as a man child after your parents kicked you out into the streets.

Grow up Isdra/Famon. There are better things to do than being a parasitic leech ruining sites out of spite because no one wants to put up with your Tumblr-tier faggotry of forcing your safe space in here.

>>59691397
KEK KEK KEK OWN THAT FAGGOT

Buuuuump thread to make Ashfags mad

>>59693106
Clearly didn't work

>>59693106
>>59694959
Then why is the Anti-Ashfag so mad?