In this thread, we will vote for the king/queen of /QST/. The path to the throne is paved with trials of strength, charm, intellect, and psychology. Choose wisely, Judges. The fate of our champion rests in your hands.
PROLOGUEIn most worlds, reality is law. In Eidolon, it is a negotiation.Eidolon is a labyrinthine city suspended in a void of shattered realities. Gods walk its obsidian streets alongside demons, devils, and ghosts. The architecture itself is alive, shifting and groaning as the malleable fabric of reality bends to the whims of the cosmos. It is a place of breathtaking, terrifying beauty. But do not let the spectacle fool you. In the shadows of its twisting alleys and floating spires, nameless horrors lurk, waiting for a moment of weakness.The city’s chaotic nature is governed by one absolute, unbreakable law: The Succession.Through rites older than time, great heroes and villains are summoned from their respective dimensions. For the next several weeks, these interdimensional champions will be pitted against one another in a series of grueling Games. Only one champion will be crowned the Monarch of Eidolon.To the victor goes absolute rule over the city for one year. They will be granted wealth, power, and authority that border on the divine.When the year has passed, the Monarch’s reign will end. The crown will be stripped and their memories of the city, their reign, and their fellow competitors will be entirely wiped from their mind. They will be dumped back into their original dimension, returning to their life as if they had never left.The gates of the Amphitheater are opening. The summons have been sent...
RULESIn this thread, you will play as an interdimensional Judge.- You must namefag to participate. This is strictly enforced.- QMs are welcome to join, but they cannot vote for their own characters or discuss their own quests, except during designated special rounds. For transparency, QMs must use their QM name/tripcode when participating.- Do not bash or harass QMs. This thread is meant to celebrate the /qst/ board and its QMs, not to publicly execute them. Keep it positive.- Do not reply to the QM's posts unless explicitly asked to do so. This keeps the thread clean and manageable. Violating this rule will result in immediate removal as a Judge.- As a Judge, you may contest any of the QM's rules. Doing so requires submitting a well-reasoned argument. The QM will evaluate the validity of your argument using logic and a die roll.- If a rule is unclear, do not ask the QM for clarification. Instead, write out your own interpretation or deduction. The QM will evaluate the validity of your interpretation using logic and a die roll.- Contestations and interpretations may be veto'd by other Judges if they provide a valid counter-argument.
REGISTRATIONBefore you can participate in the quest, you must register as a Judge. Reply to this post with:- An Ethos: A single word that determines your core ethical trait (the value you hold most dear). No two Judges may share the same Ethos.- Optional: You may write a short paragraph to develop and explain your Ethos in more detail.
NOMINATIONSNominations begin immediately in this thread. Reply to this post with one quest character you wish to nominate.- We need to elect exactly 16 nominees. If the thread gains unexpected popularity and exceeds 16 nominations, we will hold a brutal elimination round.- The nominee must be a humanoid, with a height between 3 and 8 feet. Elves, goblins, and talking monkeys are acceptable.- The nominee cannot be a god or demigod.- The nominee must originate from a /QST/ quest. It must be either a multi thread quest or a one-shot where the QM did not flake.- The nominee must be an Original Character in either an original setting or an established TTRPG campaign setting. Forgotten Realms is fine. Franchises such as Pokemon or Game of Thrones are not allowed.- QMs: If one of your characters is nominated, you may provide a short description.
>I can't nominate my nigga MarnieNot a true /qst/ tournament.
Hey guys never played in one of these>As a Judge, you may contest any of the QM's rules. Doing so requires submitting a well-reasoned argument. The QM will evaluate the validity of your argument using logic and a die roll.>If a rule is unclear, do not ask the QM for clarification. Instead, write out your own interpretation or deduction. The QM will evaluate the validity of your interpretation using logic and a die roll.Is this normal^^ because it makes no sense to me. Also why for id us from nominating Mark Delucia?
Okay let's break this down a little bit>>6443074>QMs must use their tripcode when participatingSo does this mean a QM cannot be a judge?>Do not reply to the QM's posts. Violating this rule will result in immediate removal as a judgeWhy>You may contest any of the QM's rulesWhy do rule contests and unclear rules require DICE ROLLS?>May be vetoed by other judges if they provide a valid counter-argumentOkay but this doesn't require a counter-argument? How does this influence the QM's ultimate decision?>>6443075>EthosThis seems a bit much>>6443076So no robots, anything below 2 feet or above 8 feet. No one from a franchise quest like Pokemon, Game of Thrones, DC/Marvel, etc.Again, why?>Originate from a /qst/ questHow long ago can the nominee quests be? Are we going to nominate Ruby or something like the last one? Is there a cutoff?These rules sound like they need workshopping. Also what quests have you run, QM
>>6443153Bet it's Wuxian
>>6443075TRUTHTo know thyself. To speak plainly. To not stray from your path. To seek out greater understanding.>>6443076I nominate Johnny Ando Oka from Do Your Best Quest, QM #91m10.
Rules are way too strict, especially for nominations. Registration is too weird. This tournament is going to be stillborn, but it would've been anyway since there doesn't seem to be any incentives to participate besides trying to one up other quests/ powerscale (Which goes against your "Celebrate /QST/" Aim, but so does the Nomination rules restricting a huge chunk of currently running and popular quests, for some reason), since there isn't any art being offered or made, unlike the last few tournaments. Especially because>Contestations and interpretations may be veto'd by other Judges if they provide a valid counter-argument.Is going to create endless shit-flinging if this somehow gets off the groundThis seems much more "in the moment" than the prior tournaments, which actually had planning and pools to fund art of the contestants/ winners behind them.
>>6443158Perfect.>>6443153If you disagree with the rules, you may register as a Judge and contest them formally.
>>6443172still didn't answer anything I asked
>>6443172>if you disagree with the rules play along with the rules
B8
>>6443172>If you disagree with the rules, you need to play along with methis shit is retarded
>>6443172Kek'd
Feel like this is wux bait
>>6443177>>6443180If you are unable to register, you may plead your case to a registered Judge as a ghost or spectator.
Wuxshit, I...
welp, see you all when someone actually runs a serious tourney
>>6443145This is in fact not normal. In the other tournaments we didnt larp as some metaphysical judge who has to rule lawyer to victory. It was a simple contest of>nominate character>anons vote>favorite winsHere are some examples:>waifu tournament 2021http://thisisnotatrueending.com/qstarchive/2021/4999756/>Husbando tournamenthttp://thisisnotatrueending.com/qstarchive/2022/5090023/>Nominstion and preparation thread 2024http://thisisnotatrueending.com/qstarchive/2024/5961634/>queen of /qst/ tournament 2024http://thisisnotatrueending.com/qstarchive/2024/5997910/>king of /qst/ 2024http://thisisnotatrueending.com/qstarchive/2024/6014808/I believe this qm is just way over his head on this one and some degree of control freak based on his ruleset and lack of community consensus.
>>6443075>Ethos: AttractivenessIf I participate in this tournament as a judge, I will vote based on how sexy the candidate is, based on how much lewd content they have generated from anons here or from artists on other websites, and based on how much I want the character to sit on my face.I do not want to nominate a character just yet. I'll need some time to look through old quests and decide.>>6443074I would like to ask some questions about the rules and make a few appeals.Questions: Namefagging is fine. QMs not voting for their own characters is fine (although they can still nominate them, right?). No harassment is fine. No replying to the QM posts sounds okay, but we are still allowed to ask you questions without directly replying to your posts, right?Additions: I would like to ask if we can use some of the rules from previous years.1. If the character is from a currently active quest, then the anon needs to ask permission from that QM before they can nominate. This is to let the QM know, and prevent attention if the QM wants to avoid the risk of drama.2. The quest that the character is from must have completed at least one thread, in order to avoid flavor of the month craziness seen on other boards like /co/ or /v/.Appeals: >The nominee must be a humanoid, with a height between 3 and 8 feet. Elves, goblins, and talking monkeys are acceptable.I think that this one is unfair. It seems arbitrary since it wasn't explained why "humanoid" is so important. In previous tournaments, some of the most voted on characters were non-human. For example, Beta Core from last time was a giant robot mech, yet he won the 'King of Quest' tournament due to his popularity.>The nominee must be an Original Character in either an original setting or an established TTRPG campaign setting. Forgotten Realms is fine. Franchises such as Pokemon or Game of Thrones are not allowed.I agree that the nominee must be an Original Character, but I think that it's unfair to require that they also come from an original setting. For example, Karn from Sayian Conquerer Quest was one of the most popular candidates from the previous contest. He exists in the Dragon Ball setting, but the character himself originates here on QST.It seems unfair to punish QMs who wanted to use existing IPs because they were passionate about those settings, or QMs who used those settings in order to draw more players.Lastly, I would like to request that everyone is given plenty of time before the nomination phase/round ends.Some people only check QST once per week, or even less. I'd say that a window of... idk, three weeks to gather up attention sounds fair.Once everyone is aware of the tournament, then things can proceed at a fast pace.
>>6443074End thy life wux
I am sort of interested but worried by the lack of earnest participation so far (two nominations, two judges) and by so many people thinkign it's a bait thread.>>6443123>>6443145>>6443153I also agree with these anons that any original /qst/ character regardless of height, shape power level, or setting should be eligible.
>>6443266Yeah, thread is dead on a arrival if it was an earnest attempt at a tournament because the ruleset is too strict and seems tailor made to cause shit flinging/ arguments. One or two changes won't fix it, the whole thing needs to be scrapped and if the guy is serious, run it like the prior tournaments instead of going "I might change the rules if you apply", which I really doubt that they will considering how they've reacted to the feedback in and out of this thread.
>>6443271>thread is dead on a arrivalWhat a shame... My thread ID is awesome.
>>6443275It is an amazing ID pull.
>>6443275You pulled the jackpot in the shittiest casino
I have to agree with the idea that the rulset seems really weird and autistic.Anyway, I doubt that any of my characters would get nominated if I didn't do it myself, so it's a whatever.
>>6443266>and by so many people thinkign it's a bait thread.Wuxian has been trolling for the past month or so like how he did way back but it took him a little bit to put his own name on it. He likes using different trips and handles but gives himself away. This smells like the old Wux. Can't trust him to run stuff like this in good faith. Even when Reptard ran a tourney there were a lot of bunched up panties.
>>6443288>discord dramaOh great.
I'll assume the best and go with...>>6443075>EthosRule of Cool: I'll support the most outrageous and over the top character concepts, story ideas, and sick art.Nomination pending until we see if this lasts and if the rules get amended.
>>6443074>>6443258>Question 1: QMs can still nominate their own characters, right?No, unless you can argue otherwise.>Question 2: We are still allowed to ask you questions without directly replying to your posts?Yes.>Addition 1: If the character is from a currently active quest, then the anon needs to ask permission from that QM before they can nominate.Accepted; this is reasonable.>Addition 2: The quest that the character is from must have completed at least one threadAccepted as clarification of existing rules.>Addition 3: I would like to request that everyone is given plenty of time before the nomination phase ends.Accepted; this is reasonable.>Appeal 1: The nominee must be a humanoidAccepted for argument based on precedent.>Appeal 2: The nominee must be from an original settingI would like to leave this one up for debate. It seems unfair to me that quests benefiting from the popularity of an existing IP would compete with OC quests. Isn't a large part of Karn's popularity based on the fact that his story plays out within the DBZ universe?
>>6443318simple way around the "existing IP" issue: just make it so that the character being nominated has to be an original creation by /qst/, not the entire setting
>>6443318Thank you CrownQM!For appeal #2, maybe we put up a strawpoll vote and leave it going for a while?That way people can make their case/arguments here to try and sway community opinion on which way to vote
>>6443318>It seems unfair to me that quests benefiting from the popularity of an existing IP would compete with OC quests.Many Dragon Ball, Pokemon, Digimon, ASOIAF, 40K, etc quests exist but very few last and develop big followings around an OC.
>>6443325>put up a strawpoll vote and leave it going for a while?Here it is.https://strawpoll.com/e6Z2AjRv6gN
>If a rule is unclear, do not ask the QM for clarification. Instead, write out your own interpretation or deduction. The QM will evaluate the validity of your interpretation using logic and a die roll.This is the most retarded shit I’ve ever seen. Why can’t you answer questions like a normal person? What’s the point of competing in a tournament when the spirit rules are unclear and can be changed on a coinflip?I wouldn’t want you as my QM. What quest have you ran, anyway? I noticed you didn’t answer that question back in qtg.
>>6443468Crossdressing School For Delinquents The Fall of Chicago
>>6443469with trip, please.
>>6443468It's a troll thread bro
>>6443468Uhmm buddy. Didnt you read the rules? You gotta apply as a judge before being allowed to make a case against the rules. How else are we supposed to have a tournament???
I wanted to participate in this
>>6445799you can blame wux for having no backbone and never actually running something serious. Just wait for when someone capable runs one
>>6445883Like who?
>>6445980someone capable
>>6445883Someone that does not troll in every single post they make
>>6446010This is a serious thread. The quest got raided by an army of discontent trolls, but I'm still very interested in running it. The trolls are not happy with my Judge mechanics. I stick by them. I've made them to encourage roleplay, which I believe is the purpose of this board. If the trolls don't like anything new and different, they should go back to reading Ruby Quest in the archives rather than ruining other people's fun.As for anyone who listens to the trolls, well, what can I say. That's your loss.
>>6446264>serious threadI know you're just doing this for attention but okay let's break it down:>same ID as that wuxian retard in the qtg>makes nonsensical rules and doesn't respond to anyone's questions about them because they didn't 'become a judge'>abandons the thread for a week, doesn't try to budge or make any attempt to actually run their tourney>half-assed reasoning for their mechanics no one likes, does the equivalent of a toddler crossing their arms and pouting>has not run a quest of any value ever and thinks they can run a quest tourney>refuses to actually work with any of his would be players to entertain anything that would get this tourney going>"w-w-wmmmaybe you should jus read ruby quest again instead of ruining my fuuuuun :ccc"enjoy the rest of your summer vacation :)
>>6446264I'm willing to put my faith in CrownQM, however it should definitely be mentioned that by this point, a lot of people who would have participated are now under the impression that this is a high effort troll thread.Something will need to be done in order to fix that, otherwise there will be like... six people involved in this even though it's supposed to be for the whole board.I'm not entirely sure how to actually fix the problem though. Everyone seems really pissed off about the rules situation, despite the fact that you seemed to have acted very reasonable in these >>6443318 >>6443330 two posts.Maybe it's the judge thing that is really throwing everyone off.Perhaps make it so that everyone can vote or nominate a candidate (provided that they have a registered tripcode), and have the judges merely act as QM assistants to help run the tournament?Overall, I'd suggest we try to copy the previous tournament as close as possible since it went super well. The only thing that pissed people off during the last one was how the rounds would have the candidates compete over an event rather than just getting votes for popularity.
>>6447332>high effort troll thread>high effortEhhh...
>>6447332>you seemed to have acted very reasonableBS you're trolling
>>6447332anon falling for wuxslop, many such cases
>>6447332I actually don't mind the judges aspect. Reptoid and IG both did different things to try to make it more engaging when they ran. Even if they weren't perfect, I think it made things more fun and gave people more to talk about.
>>6447482>>6447332https://youtu.be/SIouTnlXggQ
>>6447483Some people just disagree with you anon. It's okay.
>>6447483every wux thread in a nut shell
>>6447482reptard is cancelled
>>6447617Nobody cares of your discord drama
>>6447617I don't think he would participate anyway.
>>6447620it's not from discord it's fact
it's based and lesothopilled
So no tournament then?
>>6480105gee what a puzzler I dunno anon
>>6480105Tournament starts soon, just two more weeks.
>>6480116Just because Wuxian isn't doesn't mean nobody else can. Is there any actual interest?
>>6480436There is, but as this thread so deftly demonstrated it takes more than just some dunce posting a thread and saying "okay let's go". Like if anyone is actually, truly, SERIOUSLY interested then there are archived Tourneys:https://suptg.thisisnotatrueending.com/qstarchive/2024/5961634/https://suptg.thisisnotatrueending.com/qstarchive/2024/5997910/https://suptg.thisisnotatrueending.com/qstarchive/2024/6014808/https://suptg.thisisnotatrueending.com/qstarchive/2022/5090023/https://suptg.thisisnotatrueending.com/qstarchive/2021/4999756/For research. It takes thought and effort.
>>6480442I mean, frankly, it would take a lot less effort if it was done like a normal tournament instead of having a bunch of stuff about like...challenges, or whatever. It certainly made it more unique and so, but it'd probably be a LOT easier if it was done like the other boards where there's just a vote and people discuss whatever they want
>>6480444Sure, I'm not saying do what these previous Tourneys did. I'm saying 'Don't Do This: >>6443074'
