>>43554689
She'll get more spanks for looking back.

Plain old, non disciplinary birthday spankings are underused. Kind of embarrassing to be spanked by all your friends.

>>43554274
>Pumpkin was relaxing at home, when she suddenly heard a faint noise from the bathroom.
>She went to investigate.
>"Ah! Go away!" Pound whined as she opened the door.

>Pumkin immediately blushed upon seeing her brother in such a compromising position.
>"Hello, Pumpkin! Pound's been a teensy bit naughty." Pinkie said. "Could you please leave us for a bit?" She asked, hoof ready to keep punishing.
>Pumpkin wordlessly nodded, leaving the pink pony to further pinken her brother's already pink butt.
>She didn't leave immediately though, instead, she stuck around the closed door.

>"Wait, Pinkie no!", some words Pumpkin couldn't make out, an oddly long pause and spanking sounds followed.
>The filly swallowed, put her head to the door and listened in.
>Eventually...
>"Aaand done!" Pinkie said, a little too loud to be addressed to just the colt. "Let's get you downstairs so we can fix that mess."
>That was Pumpkin's queue to leave.

>In her room, the filly had many questions.
>What did Pound do to get a spanking from PINKIE PIE of all ponies? Why in that position? Did she know she was listening in?
>Either way, she found her brother's spanking... intriguing...
>She even snuck a few glances at Pinkie's "hoofwork" when Pound wasn't looking.

>Of course, neither sibling wanted to talk about it, feeling too embarrassed to do so.
>And Pinkie didn't bring it up, preferring to keep them happy.
>Eventually, everything went back to normal.
>But Pumpkin couldn't forget that moment she walked in on her brother getting such an embarrassing punishment.
>She thought about asking Pinkie about it many times, but never really found the courage to do so

Would Pumpkin eventually bite the bullet and ask Pinkie about that spanking? Or maybe Pound? Or would she leave it at that?

>>43555369
Who would it work best for?

>>43555619
Spike and Velvet?

>>43555619
Some foal just starting to age out of punishment spankings.

https://desuarchive.org/mlp/thread/35887865/#36029940

>>43555619
>>43556317
You can have a lot of spanking implements as "birthday gifts" for this scenario. A lot of fun options.

Pound and Pumpkin could work since they start as babies in the show, and their twins so it could be somewhat unique.

>>43556790
Yeah gifts are so cute. Could be initiation to pony society at the friendship school.

>>43555388
She should ask. Cute vignette, asd.

https://derpibooru.org/images/3906090

>>43558003
>https://derpibooru.org/images/3906090
Better than most "spanking machine" pics. This looks like it might actually function.

>>43556790
Or a birthday party at a house leading to an accidental discovery of a paddle or "special" hairbrush in a drawer, on a cabinet, etc.

>>43558709
Even more embarrassing with friends, because then they know for sure what the birthday foal gets spanked with.

>>43559228
Or imagine a rules and consequences chart listing swats as an option. Or finding a punishment journal.

>>43559320
Or getting to witness it for themselves.

>>43560192
Must have chiseled the wrong stone.

>>43560223
Messed up one of the Canterlot statues, so either Celestia or Twilight dealt with her rump.

>>43560726
I was looking for this edit.

That asd gallus story has stuck with me. Gallus is best spankee.

>>43562167
How so? What was your favorite thing about it? And what makes Gallus such a great spankee?

Also link?

>>43561591
Oh boy. Filly is in trouble...

>>43562494
It has great embarrassment and Pinkie talks down to him at every chance. Gallus is a great mix of trying to be cool but also being a softie.

>As Gallus was quick to find out during his stay in Ponyville, ponies favored punishing rumps for their misbehaving youth, which he was considered to be, much to his embarrassment.

>”You hit too hard!”
Pinkie chuckled. “No I don’t, silly.”
”Yes, you do!” He whined. “Professor Applejack never hit that hard!”
The pink mare rolled her eyes. “Of course she didn’t. She spanks for little fillies, not almost grown up teenagers like you.”

https://ponepaste.org/11837

File: 2727225.jpg (382 KB, 3125x2177)

382 KB JPG

>>43564156

Now that she turned them into foals, maybe a foalish punishment is in order?

>>43560726
This is perfect.

>>43563667
Humiliation ritual for newly ousted rulers. Perfect.

Have you ever been at a friend's house while they get admonished by a parent? It can be super awkward. Worse if they end up getting spanked.

Imagine getting sent home in Ponyville while you hear hoof hitting flesh through your friend's window.

>>43564630
Never happened to myself, but I'd imagine it would make for an excellent story. Especially if time outs are involved.

>>43565714
Damn, Fluttershy must have really loved that table.

>>43565942
It's the principle of the thing, and weren't they being brats that whole episode?

Is this slave cart story in the archive? Could call it "Reindeer Games".

https://desuarchive.org/mlp/thread/38349092/#38370408

>>43566009
Kind of? They were pretty hyperactive at first. Fluttershy was basically underestimating how much they can be.

>>43566376
I can add it next time for u.

>>43567227
Your amazing!

>>43566376
The neighbors have some questions seeing Anon's slave pony doing yard work (eating tall grass) with a bright red rump. Spanking your horse is legal, but she's not supposed to enjoy it.

>>43568343
Anon would be happy to answer.

>>43568343
I love in Vega's story that spanking is supposed to be for foals... Twilight just responded too well to it and Anon thought she was a teen. By the time Anon found out it was too late.

>>43568723
Cute idea. Kinda fucked up that they would have foal slaves though.

>>43565714
Is it best to get spanked first, middle or last?

>>43569791
First if you don't want the spanking.
Last if you're secretly looking forward to it.

>>43569791
Don't know about best, but worst is the middle.

Not enough time to accept the fact that your getting spanked, but just enough time to watch it happen before its your turn.

It's not uncommon for family businesses to have kids on site. What if mom is running the shop while dad is in the back disciplining his foal?

File: 444382.png (781 KB, 976x1080)

781 KB PNG

>>43570770 >>43582966

>>43570558
Pumpkin & Pound Cake are perfect for this.

>mom is running the shop while dad is in the back disciplining
Cup Cake & Pinkie Pie blush nervously as they fill each customer's order. It's the busiest hour of day and the twins picked the worst time to misbehave.
Customers try to make nervous chit-chat or strain for a peek at what's going on in the kitchen. They all pretend to ignore the shrieks & howling wails echoing thru the building as Carrot Cake takes the bread-board to a pair of naughty foal rumps.

Roseluck accidentally got two dozen oatmeal raisin cookies instead of the dozen chocolate chip she wanted. Ms. Cake repeated the order back to her, but Rose couldn't hear over Pumpkin crying for her Dad to "please, please stop" and promising to be a good filly forever.
So Roseluck got stuck with oatmeal raisin.

Even in Happy Horsie World, oatmeal raisin gets no respect.

>>43570680
https://ponepaste.org/9855 has a similar premise, with Luna making an order while the two are getting spanked in the background. I wish that anon made more stories. He's really good.

>>43570558
I bet Filthy made a few apple purchase runs to Sweet Apple Acres only to hear Applebloom getting it.

>>43571328
If Filthy is roughly Bright Mac/Pear Butter's age then Granny will remember when HE was still getting his coltie rump whupped.

File: 1391003.gif (2.04 MB, 491x491)

2.04 MB GIF

>>43573800

>>43571803
He DID seem pretty nervous when Granny threatened to talk to his grandfather about his almost-business deal with Applejack.

File: 2529294.png (2.74 MB, 1972x1110)

2.74 MB PNG

>>43576084

>>43571865
Okay by the time of the episode;
>Bright Mac & Buttercup already dead
>Medium Mac was a teenager, Applejack close, maybe tween or young teen
>Filthy Rich was courting future wife Spoiled Milk
So Filthy is likely a bit younger than Mac, Pear, Mrs. Cake and Burnt Oak.

>>43573800
Makes sense. He was clearly older then AJ.

>>43570558
What if the Woodworking master has a nephew visiting?

>>43576886
Wouldn't be much of a family business since the nephew wouldn't be working there, but it would be nice if they were a little brat, even annoying the apprentice, until the two "gift" the annoying nephew with a brand new paddle, to be tested immediately.

>>43553984
Clever theme for the time.

>>43570770
I love that fic!

File: 494046.jpg (93 KB, 482x486)

93 KB JPG

>>43582713 >>43595089 >>43596181

Why is this filly working at a hospital? Do the other nurses spank her if she messes up the work?

>>43582633
A Candy Striper maybe?

Do girls even volunteer to do that in hospitals anymore or is it just a stripper fetish now?

>>43570680
This is a good fic, with Luna knowing what's going on and remembering her own fillyhood.

>>43582966
I bet she got spanked a lot.

https://ponepaste.org/6470

True Meaning of Discipline by Ice

I love the guards reassuring her after seeing Twilight fail to hide her spanked rump.

>>43585671
Personally, my favorite part of it were the parents reaction. I love how they were light on punishment, only to realize that Celestia did not share their rearing methods.

https://derpibooru.org/images/3215831

Why is Sweetie Belle spanking Babs in the middle of the forest?

>>43588215
She's the type of "cool" filly to lead the CMCs on a wild goose chase. They were supposed to be home an hour ago and they don't even know where they are.

>>43587447
Sounds like Shining learned that lesson too.

>>43589605
But why does Sweetie have a hair brush?

>>43582633
Maybe its a similar apprenticeship to the woodworking colt.

>>43582713
Would they accept someone so young for that?

>>43578608
What if they had him help make it, not knowing what it was? It's a cheese board, champ.

>>43595089
>someone so young?
I don't know but it's Happy Horse World, they let fillies drive parade floats and shit. Besides, how old do you think she is based on a few seconds appearance?

>>43582633
>Do the other nurses spank her
I think that's a bit much but if her Mom is Head Nurse it might be a different story.

>>43588215
>Why is Sweetie Belle spanking Babs in the middle of the forest?
If you have to ask then it's a dumb pairing.

https://derpibooru.org/images/3589501

>Scootaloo models for a stock photo company
>Rainbow suggested it as a way to earn some bits
>They both thought that would be the end of it
>Then these posters started being sold
>And they were POPULAR
>The contract said no royalties
>But it also said nothing that damages the model's reputation

>Scootaloo is mortified
>Foals call her Spank-a-loo
>As her guardian, Rainbow sues on Scoot's behalf

>But this is big business
>Rainbow got a good law-pony
>Brought Scoot to the fancy law office in Canterlot
>Scoot broke down in tears just talking about it
>She'll work on contingency, after explaining what that is

>But the poster maker will not give up her golden goose
>She also found a great lawyer

>This leads to court
>And unfortunately for Scootaloo, a lot of publicity

>The whip-smart defendant's lawyer makes a defense in open court
"Defamation requires a FALSE claim. Let's hear from Miss Scootaloo under oath."
Have you ever been spanked?
>She lies initially
"No, never!"
>Her lawyer interjects
"Now Scootaloo, you told me and this court you would be brave and honest on the witness stand. I know it's embarrassing for you, but are you positive you've never been spanked?"
"I mean, yeah..."
"Have you ever been put in the corner?"

>They went through the whole poster.
>Almost everything she had already experienced

>Then it was Rainbow's turn
>Have you ever spanked Scootaloo?

>She cross-examined Scootaloo's friends and enemies
>Classmates and even ponies from different schools

"Your honor, spanking is a common punishment, and Miss Scootaloo has experienced most activities on the poster. It cannot be reputationally damaging if it's true."

>That's the defense. Is Scootaloo's lawyer good enough to counter it? A blushing, tearful filly's social standing is at stake.

File: 3815864.jpg (307 KB, 1600x2000)

307 KB JPG

>>43596964
Oh, poor Scoots. By the time this trial ends, the entirety of Equestria will know every little detail about how she gets spanked.

>Rainbow suggested it as a way to earn some bits
Perhaps this is one thing she shouldn't be listening to Rainbow about...
>As her guardian, Rainbow sues on Scoot's behalf
Couldn't she just get Twilight to help? She's a national hero and personal friend to a princess. Also a Wonderbolt. It feels like this would be an easy case just with that.
>And unfortunately for Scootaloo, a lot of publicity
Courts in Equestria are rare, so it's always a big deal when they happen.
>It cannot be reputationally damaging if it's true."
Seems like kind of a weak argument, considering the emotional distress that occurred because of the poster.
>That's the defense. Is Scootaloo's lawyer good enough to counter it?
Given everything above, yea I'd say the lawyer has a good shot.

>>43596181
>how old do you think she is
I guess 10 comparing her model to other ponies? Maybe 12? Hard to say. Definitely still within spanking age.

>Mom is Head Nurse
Now that has story potential!

>>43600439
If nothing else she must have experience spanking newborns to get them to breathe.

>>43596964
Scoot on the witness stand would be deadly cute.

>Have you ever been put in the corner?
>Yes.
>Have you ever been made to touch two walls with your muzzle?
>Yes.
>Have you ever had your mouth washed out with soap?
She sighs.
>Yes...

>>43603436
And Rainbow has to confirm it all.

>>43558294
looking like it would function mean very little when considering that the world has magic.

>>43606190
With pictures.

>>43608733
What did she do to earn such a harsh paddling?

>>43607738
I'm just objecting to the "spanking machine" pics that are just nonsense stick arms coming out of nowhere. Lazy art...straight in the reject bin.
Example; https://derpibooru.org/images/1935937

>>43558003
This one at least put some effort into making something that looks (kinda) realistic.

>>43612099
I'd say a proper pony spanking machine would have the spankee strapped down with their rump sticking out. One magic crystal below would levitate a spanking implement like a paddle, the other, on top would cast a light on the spankee's rump. The levitating crystal would do the spanking and would be limited to the area touched by the light of the other crystal, meaning the paddle whacks would be limited to the butt, thus leading to a tireless magical spanker and a very sore spankee. As long as the spanking crystals are fed magic, they could go on potentially forever.

>>43606190
Somehow this circus gets Diamond Tiara, pre-redemption. Gloating, under oath, how she is NEVER spanked and makes fun of foals who are. Her parents don't care. She is a key witness for the case, showing the reputational harm of being spanked.

>>43613530
Funnily enough, her bullying would help lead Scootaloo to victory, only to be rewarded with a spanking.

>>43613288
They weren't super realistic or described in detail, but I liked Vega's spanking machine stories.

>>43617105
Vega made machine stories?

>>43617938
The Sparkle Spanker 2000, and I think the one where Rainbow flies around Ponyville.

>>43619048
I never knew those were Vega fics.

>>43553984
I don't think she realizes what a birthday spanking is.

Fluttershy: Oh, I'm sorry. I was just having fun.
Applejack: Well, you can have all the fun you want as long as it's while you're beatin' the hide off of Braeburn's team.
-
Applejack: I hear the whole town's already plannin' a parade for when you get back after whuppin' Appleloosa! That should feel pretty good!
Fluttershy: [nervous] It should...?

https://mlp.fandom.com/wiki/Transcripts/Buckball_Season

>>43622354
Spanking are canon.

>>43621800
Hot.

>>43621800
If Sunset won in the EQG movie and attacked Equestria:

If you were to get sent to Equestria as a filly or colt, which pony would you want to get spanked by either from an adult or foal perspective?

>>43623808
There's also Twilight saying her cheeks are sore.

>>43629722
I'm sure both Velvet and Celestia dealt with her rump in the past.

>>43627773
>which pony would you want to get spanked by
The basics; parents and maybe teachers.
Anything else just seems like a contrived situation.

>>43629722
Which episode?!?!

>>43633017
Which one in particular?

>>43603436
Love all of these!

Imagine it was a more humiliating person being asked, like an adult, rainbow herself, rarity or Celestia haha who’s generations old. And they ask her how recently! To see if it’s still relevant to the case haha.

>>43634169
Oh yes! That would work perfectly!

The defense gets Rainbow on the stand.

>Miss Dash, if you had known spanking would be implied on this poster, would you have allowed Scootaloo to be featured on it?
>No.
>Why?
>Spankings are embarrassing. They're for little fillies.
>When was the last time you were spanked as punishment, Miss Dash?
>Can I pass?

>>43635686
She would get nervous and maybe even lie on oath which may be a spankable offense in of itself.

Oh dear that number of days since the last spanking may be swiped down to 0….

File: 1615474910.sugarcraftprod(...).png (709 KB, 768x960)

709 KB PNG

>>43639466 >>43642362

Bump

>>43639266
Time out idea. 10 minute time out, no moving, no counting out loud. The pony in time out has to say when 10 minutes have passed. More than 30 seconds off and they have to start over.

Would make the time out even more boring and humiliating.

>>43633138
>Which one in particular?
To be honest, I usually don't have one in mind to begin. I usually start with a scenario that might lead to a spanking and decide what characters fit it best later.

>11

>>43639266
sad colt ;(

>>43642362
Deserved though.

File: 2629129.png (235 KB, 735x1000)

235 KB PNG

>>43644232 >>43644711

Little Twiley is learning a lot at Princess Celestia's school.
Her old school didn't even have a potions class.
Twilight wants to learn everything but the class is SOOOO SLOOOOOWWWW.
She wants to practice some more complicated spells at home.
>Gonna need a cauldron.
Hmmm, Dad's big new sauce pot would work.
Twiley is not supposed to touch daddy's cooking stuff.
But this is not for cooking, so it's okay, right?

>1 hour later
Oh crap, oh crap, oh crap
It's a disaster.
Twilight got the spell wrong and her potion ate straight thru the pot
Worse, it spilled down into the stove and ruined that too.
Twiley isn't even supposed to TOUCH the stove unless Mommy or Daddy or Shiny is there to supervise
Oh crap, oh crap, oh crap...
>"What am I gonna do?"

A.) Be honest. Admit she broke the rules and throw herself on the mercy of the court?

B.) Play dumb. Maybe changelings broke in and did it.

C.) Blame Spike.

Or something else?

>>43643615
Blame Spike, the parents play along and act like they're going to spank him.

Maybe take him alone into their bedroom and pretend spank him. When Twily doesn't confess even after a few "swats," that means she's getting the manebrush.

>>43643615
Clearly this is Spike's fault. Blame him.

I don't think we have any visits from friends (of the spankee or family members) during a spanking. That could be an interesting interruption.

>>43645273
There's https://ponepaste.org/11658 . It has Rainbow walking in on Scootaloo's spanking. There's even time out. No interruption though.

>>43627773
As a foal, probably someone like Fluttershy, assuming she'd go easy on me.
Out of universe, Rainbow.

>>43635686
And this same question gets spanked to every witness.

>>43645300
I'm imagining "no, don't stop on my account". With the spankee embarrassed.

>>43646395
This would work with older visitors. Maybe a parent? Or Celestia?

>>43556790
Pound and Pumpkin giving each other spankings.

>>43646395
Another idea I've had is a teacher making a house call. Then the parents showing how serious they are by spanking on the spot or asking the teacher to do it themselves.

See through paddles and stools to see the impact and aftermath.

>>43647813
Perfect for judicial cases, where each whack and every bit of redness needs to be measured perfectly for legal reasons.

>>43648136
Machines or magic could be useful there.

>>43648481
definitely. Maybe a invisibility spell for a paddle

>>43646964
Sisterswap is a great spanking premise.

I see the archive got updated. Thank you archive anon! I hope your waifu fucks you senseless in a nice comfy bed.

>>43646964
Big brush.

File: full.png (413 KB, 1245x1153)

413 KB PNG

>>43652341 >>43652496

>>43649829
>Thank you archive anon!
np :))
>I hope your waifu fucks you senseless in a nice comfy bed.
that would be Celestia with some serious bdsm equipment

>>43651477
Celestia could simply use her magic for BDSM.

>>43651477
True that, she probably dosen't need a strapon to peg a guy until he faints. She can probably form a painful dick with her magic alone.

>>43652496
Meant for
>>43652341

>>43649747
"My sister is the most strict!"
"No mine is!"
Hilarity ensues.

>>43653786
But who ends up being right?

>>43654880
Apple Bloom.

>>43649747
The procedure differences would be more exciting than the intensity.

Who uses corner time? Before or after?
What implement?
Who has to fetch a switch?
Who gets it in the kitchen or a bedroom?
Who gets it out in public?
Who gets to mope around and who has to go right back to chores?

>>43655304
Why?

>>43653373
Dashie's gonna have some fun with him.

File: 3256780.jpg (59 KB, 692x604)

59 KB JPG

>>43659605 >>43667643

>>43656066
Are we looking at only CMC or do others siblings count? If it's only CMC:

>Who uses corner time? Before or after?
Before, Applejack. After, Rarity.
>What implement?
Applejack: switch
Rarity: Big fancy wooden hairbrush.
Rainbow: Her insanely powerful wings.
>Who has to fetch a switch?
Whoever is with Applejack.
>Who gets it in the kitchen or a bedroom?
It depends on the location, but AJ would use it the most. Rarity would prefer the bedroom, either her's or the guest's and Rainbow would find a cloud to spank on if it isn't at home. Otherwise bedroom for her as well.
>Who gets it out in public?
Once again, depends, but AJ would be the most likely to not care, but Rainbow would also not really prioritize privacy when finding a spank cloud.
>Who gets to mope around and who has to go right back to chores?
Farms need chores, so AJ would make the spanked filly do them. It's why she doesn't really do corner time. Rarity would use corner and Rainbow would just let them mope around. Maybe keep them on the cloud for a while if possible.

>>43658350
this pic is perfect

>>43658350
Do you think Spike gets to spank her sometimes?

>>43657666
All good answers. Applejack would not hesitate to whoop a behind in public.

I love how cute this pic is. Even though it takes many days for spank marks to go away, naughty fillies are right back in action the next day. Those who see them just quietly chuckle, confident that the girls won't get in trouble... as long as their rumps are sore.

It's adorable that tough Scoots got spanked the least hard. In the comic this is from, it's her first time, and Rainbow uses her wing.

Maybe pony rumps are as described in Red-Emption of a Showmare. Earth pony butts are strong and hardy, while unicorn butts and by extension, pegasi butts are less able to withstand punishment. Apple bucking is practically designed to strengthen the glutes and make Apple foals able to get bright red hides with only reasonable amounts of tears.

https://fimfetch.net/story/107744/redemption-of-a-showmare

>>43658967
He would be the right age for it. Maybe a little scorch to go with the swats.

>>43658350
May as well rename it to Princess's Spot.

>>43659903
Burning claw swats. Extra painful, but one of the few things that can get through a naughty alicorn filly. It's why Spike is often allowed to punish her.

>>43660950
Castle staff use it.

Are stocks good for spanking? What about before or after?

File: 2448322.png (29 KB, 709x437)

29 KB PNG

>>43665317

>>43662392
Technically, anything that leaves a pony's butt in a spankable position is usable for a spanking. In the case of stocks, it can work for before, during and after.

File: 3378631.png (148 KB, 477x519)

148 KB PNG

>>43664629 >>43669190

Are crystal ponies harsher with their foals?

>>43662392
yes

>>43663378
I think there was a discussion about this in a previous thread. Some Equestrian ponies may have direct ancestry to crystal ponies, who may have interbred 1000 years ago. Of course, those same family members may still be alive to potentially babysit their young descendants, only to teach them how foal rearing was handled 1000 years ago.

>>43664629
Visiting ponies are horrified to see how harsh they treat colts and fillies. Some vandals on a senior trip get crystal justice.

>>43662392
>stocks?
>>43662826
>>43663994
There's no historical record of it ever being done. Probably because it puts dangerous strain on the neck. If a spankee thrashes too violently their neck could be broken.

If you wanted to use stocks you'd need a table for the spankee to lay on and be strapped down to, for their own safety so they don't thrash.

>>43665317
Display only, got it.

>>43665317
Technically, it may work differently for ponies, given they have different autonomy then humans.

>>43665198
I bet they have special crystal paddles for spankings.

>>43657666
>others siblings
What other sibling options are there?

>>43667643
Twilight, Shining, Thunderlane, Celestia.

>>43663378
Cute filly.

Celestia (pony world):
>Sunset Shimmer. I have always found a warm rump to be a clarifying experience for a filly. Wouldn't you agree?

>>43670277
Before or after the spanking?

>>43670006
I really want to know who these ponies are.

>>43671086
During/after. Really make her admit she needs it.

>>43671902
But at what age should she admit it?

>>43671248
I just want it to get finished.

Individual implement marks are visible if a spanking is not long.

>>43674488
And what is the best implement for that?

>>43675139
Hand. Hoof isn't the same.

Cane and paddle are also quite distinctive. Hole marks from the paddle too.