[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
4chan
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.




File: 1793178418836757[1].mp4 (2.06 MB, 720x1280)
2.06 MB
2.06 MB MP4
How true is this? Why was Hitler so obsessed with the Jews? Are Jews just ordinary people randomly persecuted by big meanies for no reason? Or are all Jews complicit in a gargantuan conspiracy to topple vvestern civilization? Or something inbetween? Why was there a wildly disproportionate number of jewish leftists, billionaires and trans rights activists both in Weimar Germany and the modern world?
>>
>>18761933
>Are Jews just ordinary people
They're not people by any metric
>>
>>18761933
>Why was Hitler so obsessed with the Jews?

Because he stupidly believed they were responsible for Germany's defeat in WW1 when in fact they were the strongest supporters of Germany in WW1 and fiercely opposed to Tsarist Russia.

>Are Jews just ordinary people randomly persecuted by big meanies for no reason?

Most Jews are ordinary people, some Jews are elite scumbags, just like most Germans are ordinary people while some
Germans are elite scumbags.

>Or are all Jews complicit in a gargantuan conspiracy to topple vvestern civilization?

Obviously not.

>Why was there a wildly disproportionate number of jewish leftists

Because the right hated Jews historically. Think about it like this: If one side hates you and wants you dead and the other accepts you and wants to improve your condition in life, who would you support? The latter right? Thus Jews historically supported the left over the right. Though note that this was mostly limited to secular and Reform Ashkenazim. Practicing Othodox Ashkenazim, along with Sephardim and Mizrahim in general, have usually been hostile or at best neutral to left wing politics.

>billionaires

Ashkenazim have historically been very good with money, with Europeans restricting them to moneylending. Being good with money leads to being financially successful. Ashkenazim have also been very entrepreneurial, artistic, and communal, meaning they've been very likely to start businesses, engage in music and acting, and support each other in their pursuits. Thus they have found success. Again, this is primarily Ashkenazim, not as much with the Sephardim or Mizrahim who tend to be more average in life.

>trans rights activists both in Weimar Germany and the modern world

See what I said about secular Jews and the left before. Though the left has begun turning on Jews more than the right in many cases, secular and Reform Ashkenazim remain primarily left wing as they were more accepted among the left.
>>
>>18761948
Good post.
>>
>>18761948
Well said
>>
>>18761933
>Why was Hitler so obsessed with the Jews?
While Hitler did have an obsession with hating Jews, it was part of a larger strategy of conquering German society by splitting off smaller groups to scapegoat them and build up a core of support. Here's some American antinazi propaganda that I think genuinely does a good job of explaining it without being too over the top.
https://youtu.be/vGAqYNFQdZ4
>>
>>18761933
>wildly disproportionate number of jewish leftists, billionaires and trans rights activists both in Weimar Germany and the modern world?
High IQ, intelligent people tend to be incredibly degenerate so that's why you see them have freaky fetishes like transsexuals, cuckoldry, pedophilia, etc.
>>
>>18761933
As to why he hated Judaism

1. Enormous disproportionate influence in positions of soft power like media production, publishing, advertising, finance, and academia
2. Large representation in subversive progressive moments that are contrary to reactionary/conservative causes like feminism, anticolonialism, anti racism, communism, gender theory, etc.
3. Ironically, culture that insists on superiority and seperation from those outisde the tribe, whether it be rooted in religion, culture, or race.
4. Lack of proselytizing and an insular, cronyist religion that creates networks of nepotistic influence and alienates non-Jews. Further exacerbated by dogma that permits mistreatment and manipulation of those outside the group
5. Covert hostility to European values and cultures, owed mostly to Christendom and historical conflicts between Jews and Christians
>>
>>18761933
Why do you think the video needs any extra explanation? They came, and began replacing the well polished culture with their retarded stuff. Why do you think there needs to be sone irrational hidden motive to hate it?
>>
>>18762051
retard
>>18762053
there wasn't a large scale migration of Jews from the east, and almost all persecutions were targeting asimilated german jews who lived in germany for centuries
>>
>>18762060
Not an argument retard
>>
109 countries can't be wrong.
>>
File: 1890-C~1.jpg (186 KB, 1064x1390)
186 KB JPG
>>18761933
Jews were persecuted by Hitler for retarded very insane antisemitic reasons, but Jews were "persecuted" in Medieval Europe for very real reasons. Negative attitudes towards Jews, due to the role swaths of the Jewish community would play in the middle ages (Slavers, Tax Farmers, Loan Sharks, force conversion of Christian women into Ashkenazi rape slaves, generally all round Protected by European crown and nobility to step on the neck of serfs) led to long term antisemitic attitudes into the modern age especially as many Jews continued to take up the role of Capitalists, Financiers, Loan Sharks etc into the modern ages, which was also seized upon by Occult Conspiracy Theorists at the time (Theosophical Society) which directly led to the retardo antisemitic theories of Nazi Germany.
>with Europeans restricting them to moneylending.
Europeans never restricted Jews into moneylending and tax farming. Moneylending and tax farming was just a career chosen by Jews because they had the freedom to do it vs most Christians and it was extremely profitable.
>>
>>18762068
>Europeans never restricted Jews into moneylending and tax farming

Of course the extent depends on the time and place in history but to say never is factually incorrect. Jews were largely prohibited from joining guilds (working trades) and prohibited from owning land (becoming farmers). Moneylending was one field they were not prohibited from and in fact encouraged to do. Jews were even brought to nations for this purpose, such as the Normans bringing Jews to England. So while Europeans may not have passed a law forcing them to do moneylending or have told them specifically to work in moneylending or else, they did close off almost every other avenue for employment, making it defacto mandatory for them if they wanted to earn a living.
>>
File: 1772693728812.png (1.28 MB, 686x1024)
1.28 MB PNG
>>18762051
Correct.
He explains it himself in Mein Kampf and his speeches
>>
>>18762080
Are Jews really going to choose to be shitty serfs and farmers and in the muck with dirty "goyim", over basically being auto-gentry in control of the most profitable fields in European society where you even have massive amount of control over nobility while being directly protected by the crown?
Nothing stopped Jews from all being scribes, or doctors, apothecaries, metalsmithing etc and all sorts of urban professions, and many went into those fields, but lets be real, there is a reason finance/slavery/tax farming dominated the Jewish career choices (something most never even had a chance of choosing at the time) and it wasn't because they were "forced" into it.
>>
>>18762095
>Nothing stopped Jews from all being scribes, or doctors, apothecaries, metalsmithing etc and all sorts of urban professions, and many went into those fields

Yes, when they were allowed to work in trades and medicine, they absolutely did. They were even considered overrepresented and influential in medicine in the Islamic world, and to a lesser extent in Europe, before bans were placed on their practice in the 14th and 15th centuries. Let's not be intentionally obtuse and pretend like Jews had no legal restrictions placed on them in Europe regarding employment or living in general.

Moneylending factually was one of the few trades they could do with the European community at large that faced little restrictions or prohibitions and that was actually encouraged by Europeans. A Jewish metalsmith would often be ostracized by European guilds and find no work among them. While a moneylender would not face such restrictions.
>>
>>18762060
Much of them came from what is now Ukraine, and saying the middle ages ended for them in 1900 is probably an understatement.
>>
>>18761933
Read August Kubizek, Hitler already disliked jews before WW1 and did some research about tjem. He even attended a jewish wedding, if I'm remembering well
>>
>>18761948
>he stupidly believed they were responsible for Germany's defeat in WW1 when in fact they were the strongest supporters of Germany in WW1 and fiercely opposed to Tsarist Russia
Polish Jews wanted independence from Germany and Austria, Hitler would encounter Polish Jewish migrants in Vienna while the Prussian Junkers to the north wanted to keep control over their patch of Poland. They were seen as supporting the breakup of the German and Austrian Empires as well as communists and socialists in large numbers, the Spartacists for example were composed mostly of Polish Jews.

>Europeans restricting them to moneylending
Meme, Italian bankers prove this was irrelevant certainly before the renaissance and the major changes that took place in Europe.

>Ashkenazim have also been very entrepreneurial, artistic, and communal, meaning they've been very likely to start businesses, engage in music and acting, and support each other in their pursuits.
If they have superior abilities why wouldn't they use it to scam gentiles and engage in nepotism to succeed in finance then use their financial resources to infiltrate the government, law and media? They are not only superior in ability they are morally superior?

>the left has begun turning on Jews
only in the past few years, also Jews are still in full support of trans rights due to their genderless god elohim and the sense that trannies are trying to follow in xer example
>>
>>18761933
It's all biblical prophecy see Isaiah 53
>>
>>18763407
>Polish Jews wanted independence from Germany and Austria, Hitler would encounter the Spartacists for example were composed mostly of Polish Jews.

Polish Jews, as with Poles in general, yes. But German and Austro-Hungarian Jews strongly supported their nations in the war, with German Jews even having hopes of fully assimilating eastern Jews into a German cultural identity.

Regarding Spartacists, the Ashkenazim support for the left was already explained.

https://ww1.habsburger.net/en/chapters/jewish-soldiers-austro-hungarian-army
https://www.myjewishlearning.com/article/wwi-and-the-jews/
https://www.liverpooluniversitypress.co.uk/doi/10.3828/polin.2025.37.239
https://www.jstor.org/content/oa_chapter_edited/j.ctv1zvc7qq.13?seq=7

>Meme, Italian bankers prove this was irrelevant certainly before the renaissance

Italian states heavily employed Jewish moneylenders and also applied restrictions to Jewish employment, though it depends on what state and time as Italy of course was not a unified state

https://bse.eu/research/working-papers/banks-and-development-jewish-communities-italian-renaissance-and-current

>If they have superior abilities why wouldn't they use it to scam gentiles

I have no idea what you're going on about here. I'm referring to Ashkenazim culture which is what contributed to their success among ethnicities. Valuing education and being industrial all while having close communal bonds leads to success.

>Jews are still in full support of trans rights due to their genderless god

Okay? Germanic Europeans and Spaniards also have strong support for LGBT as well. This isn't unique to Ashkenazim. And again, I already explained secular and Reform Ashkenazim and their tendency to the left

https://tgeu.org/trans-rights-map/
https://prri.org/research/mapping-support-for-lgbtq-rights-across-the-50-states-insights-from-prris-2025-american-values-atlas/
>>
>>18761933
>Why was Hitler so obsessed with the Jews
He believed all of human history was a proxy war between Aryans and Jews to gain mastery over the world.
Read Mein Kampf if you think I'm misrepresenting him
>>
>>18761933
>>18761933
>Germany post-WW1 border
Should had use Greater Germany
BTC
bc1qtm4rep7kyp2p28hlkfktpnd0j7uew47vnt2mev
LTC
ltc1q9xlaysse0mpfwf025esd69kt9zu3md22gh23du
ETH
0x6abA18D203520c8F90ca63eE7426a7bC345D98e6
SOL
E5ekoiauCR8yiNp451dmuPzhUxo84P5x3m9WJBK5kxZe
XRP
r3jYXNdMk2Vz5hXhKCKE9re8uz93JQFG1r
DOGE
DSBq5jRWkiwmEh1G7zBwmQDgRkvRr61fmb
XMR
85CTwq5wGjWZw5GgzgwZPrHyZxpLXMK5oZSSSk5j4x9w1bpqzisaWAUZYaAPfh6rP2MZJcaFqF1XmEzkw6YCqJSS2Txu6Z8




Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.